The Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC) introduced late final month that it could transfer away from utilizing a check it designed to search for SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19).
It was the primary COVID check to obtain emergency use authorization (EUA) from the Meals & Drug Administration (FDA) within the early days of the pandemic. However with COVID-19 nonetheless surging in lots of components of the nation, the necessity for testing actually hasn’t gone away. So why is the CDC ditching this check now?
Might it’s (as one viral tweet claimed) as a result of this COVID check had been recalled after failing a full assessment? Or that the FDA discovered this check was inaccurate and could not distinguish between COVID and the flu?
Nope, nope, and nope. There isn’t any reality behind these claims, however the true clarification is fairly easy. Here is why the CDC’s taking again its EUA request for this explicit COVID check on the finish of 2021.
You do not have to dig deep to seek out the principle purpose the CDC desires to cease utilizing its authentic polymerase chain response (PCR) check for SARS-CoV-2—simply take a look at the company’s announcement. It encourages labs to modify to checks that may search for this coronavirus and flu viruses on the identical time. The CDC itself has even designed a check that may just do that, and it received the inexperienced mild from the FDA in July 2020.
“The CDC has acknowledged that it could turn out to be more and more essential to check for each COVID and different viruses, like influenza and RSV [respiratory syncytial virus] as we transfer into the autumn and winter,” says Matthew Binnicker, PhD, director of medical virology in Mayo Clinic’s Division of Scientific Microbiology.
That does not imply the CDC’s authentic check (often known as CDC 2019-nCoV Actual-Time RT-PCR Diagnostic Panel) was falsely selecting up influenza infections as COVID circumstances, although. Fairly, it was solely in search of SARS-CoV-2 and ignoring genetic materials from different viruses fully. It could not inform a lab whether or not your pattern contained any viral materials, simply whether or not it had genetic materials from the COVID coronavirus. And the genetic materials it appears to be like for is extremely particular, sort of like a singular fingerprint, so it might’t be confused with that of one other virus.
“Once you develop and submit a brand new check for authorization from the FDA, it’s a must to present that you simply checked the particular genetic sequence you are testing for in opposition to related and associated organisms, and that there isn’t any cross-reactivity. Your check must be particular for that organism you are attempting to measure,” explains Dwayne Breining, MD, government director and medical director of Northwell Well being Laboratories. “There is a purpose why the individuals who developed this kind of testing received a Nobel prize again within the day. PCR checks are among the many most correct medical checks which have ever been developed.”
Backside line: The CDC’s authentic PCR check for COVID is not going away due to inaccurate outcomes—it is simply that there are extra complete checks obtainable that may assist medical doctors work out whether or not you may have COVID, the flu, or another bug, and provide the proper remedy. Taking this check “off the market” helps push labs to undertake these different checks that may examine for a number of viruses.
Specialists say that, whereas not explicitly talked about within the announcement, there may be one other large purpose behind the CDC’s newest transfer. It has to do with the sheer variety of checks which have obtained EUA because the CDC’s PCR check first debuted in February 2020, when there was an enormous want for testing and no different choices within the US. The CDC, as a federal company, was uniquely positioned to quickly create an efficient check and deploy it to government-run labs throughout the nation.
“The CDC does this in particular circumstances for brand new and rising pathogens, like COVID. That they had additionally completed the same factor for Ebola and the Zika virus,” says Dr. Breining.
Since then, tons of of latest checks have turn out to be obtainable throughout the nation. And whereas they usually depend on the identical PCR expertise used within the CDC’s first check, lots of the newer checks are rather more environment friendly for labs to course of, permitting them to conduct way more testing each day with out compromising accuracy.
“The CDC isn’t actually within the testing enterprise per se,” explains Dr. Breining. He explains that the CDC rolled out the primary check rapidly to jumpstart the nation’s capacity to check for SARS-CoV-2. That paved the way in which for different teams, like personal corporations and nonprofit organizations, to develop new COVID-19 checks. “As soon as the trade is on its toes, the CDC usually backs away from the scenario to allow them to transfer onto the subsequent factor,” he says. “That sample of the CDC growing the testing then backing away is typical.”
In different phrases, that is simply enterprise as standard—not a mirrored image of the standard or accuracy of the unique PCR check for COVID.
The CDC’s transfer should not trigger any points for individuals who want a COVID check. For one, it is solely withdrawing its EUA request for its personal check. It will not impression the tons of of different checks nonetheless in use.
Plus, only a few labs within the nation are nonetheless utilizing this check, says Dr. Breining. The CDC has solely been offering its authentic PCR check for COVID to sure public well being laboratories run by the federal government—not hospitals or industrial laboratories the place many COVID checks are processed. These which might be nonetheless utilizing this check may have till the tip of the yr to modify to a different choice, such because the CDC’s “multiplex assay,” which checks for COVID and a number of flu strains, per the company’s announcement.
“For essentially the most half, it’s going to change nothing. Nearly each laboratory moved past the CDC COVID testing assay many months in the past. If an individual did occur to make use of a lab that used the CDC assay, that lab would have converted to a different check and it is going to be seamless for the one that will get testing completed,” says Dr. Breining.
What’s extra, transferring towards complete testing for a number of viruses on the identical time can supply main advantages to each people and public well being. Realizing which kind of an infection a affected person has provides medical doctors the chance to prescribe the proper remedy early on, says Dr. Binnicker. It is going to additionally present officers with extra knowledge on clusters of COVID, the flu, and different infections, to allow them to “save time and assets” throughout flu season, the CDC factors out.
Within the meantime, medical doctors and public well being specialists proceed to battle the myths in regards to the CDC’s current announcement and the COVID-19 “infodemic.”
“Any time a corporation or firm or authorities company takes one thing away, there’s at all times going to be questions, and persons are going to fill that vacant house with misinformation and rumors about what occurred,” says Dr. Binnicker. “However the consensus within the laboratory testing group and healthcare group is that the CDC applied their check in the course of the early phases of the pandemic to reply to an unmet want, and now that want has been met by greater than 200 completely different diagnostic checks that, in some circumstances, are quicker and typically present physicians with extra info.”
The knowledge on this story is correct as of press time. Nevertheless, because the scenario surrounding COVID-19 continues to evolve, it is potential that some knowledge have modified since publication. Whereas Well being is attempting to maintain our tales as up-to-date as potential, we additionally encourage readers to remain knowledgeable on information and suggestions for their very own communities through the use of the CDC, WHO, and their native public well being division as assets.
To get our high tales delivered to your inbox, join the Wholesome Residing publication