Skip to content
Home » Why a brand new left celebration led by Jeremy Corbyn is a foul concept

Why a brand new left celebration led by Jeremy Corbyn is a foul concept


The report by the Telegraph that Jeremy Corbyn is contemplating turning his Peace and Justice Mission (PJP) into a brand new left celebration shouldn’t be as loopy because it sounds. 

All through a lot of the twentieth century, Britain had an efficient, high-profile Communist Get together. In different European international locations – for instance Spain and Finland – events of the novel left govern in coalition with social democrats on the nationwide stage and exert leverage on centre-left governments even the place they’re excluded from workplace. 

A PJP celebration would bomb electorally but it surely may present a house for tens of hundreds of activists fed up with Keir Starmer. Launching it now, nonetheless, with Corbyn and his closest collaborators because the organisational hub, can be a really dangerous concept. Listed here are 5 the explanation why.

1. The undesirable periphery. The individuals who wander round Labour convention, surreptitiously shoving leaflets into your hand saying the anti-Semitism scandal was a “rip-off”; who consider that the rebellion in Kazakhstan is an intelligence operation by the CIA; and that the 2013 chemical weapons assault on opposition-held Japanese Ghouta was staged by the Syrian rebels themselves. 

This small however loud minority have been drawn to Corbynism at its peak, and it took a whole lot of work by grassroots activists in constituency Labour Events to cease them tainting the model. They’d flock to a Corbyn-led celebration, and – being small at delivery – it must erect bureaucratic buildings simply as stringent as Labour has to maintain them out, or find yourself in a reputational morass.

2. The Inexperienced Get together. The Greens in England and Wales reportedly have 53,000 members and are at the moment polling in excessive single figures. Their single MP, Caroline Lucas, collaborates actively with the pro-Stay, pro-constitutional reform (ie, distinctly non-Corbynite) wing of the Labour left. Their voters, lots of them younger, have a firmly un-Labourite imaginative and prescient of the world and what’s improper with it. 

They’re supporting the Greens as a result of they’ve a inexperienced, not a social democratic, critique of capitalism. The very best Labour can hope for on the subsequent common election is to influence them to vote tactically to kick the Conservatives out – however the celebration itself is right here to remain as a left pole of attraction exterior Labour, and not possible to disregard.

Content material from our companions
The shrinking road to net zero
The tree-planting misconception
Is your business ready for corporate climate reporting?

3. The insurance policies. I do know what Jeremy Corbyn stands for. What’s exceptional, nonetheless, in regards to the Peace and Justice Mission is the absence of coverage work within the two years because it was shaped.

There are quite a few left assume tanks – Autonomy, the New Economics Basis, Widespread Wealth – and a whole lot of coverage work popping out of the massive commerce unions that might form the programme of a radical left celebration. However the PJP has proven scant curiosity in them. 

Any left celebration price founding would wish a critique of capitalism, a place on geopolitics, a technique to defend democracy in opposition to the far proper, and a transparent imaginative and prescient of its path to energy – together with the alliances it desires to make and the ways it desires to undertake. Even when I wished a brand new celebration, I wouldn’t need its insurance policies determined by the folks round Corbyn who introduced us “Pink Brexit”.

4. Labour stays a mass celebration of the working class. Sure it’s at the moment managed by a mix of the centre and the appropriate. However it’s a mass, lively celebration of working folks, supported by the commerce unions – and it has a transparent coverage platform distinct from the Tories: a £28bn-a-year inexperienced transformation programme; office rights from day one; and redistributive tax and spending insurance policies to deal with the gasoline disaster, for instance. 

The great thing about a celebration that exists to characterize organised staff is that it’s by no means merely outlined by its ideology – however by the interaction of forces performing upon and inside it. These (because the Blairites discovered) can change.

5. A Labour authorities is significant, and time is brief. Solely a Labour-led authorities can decarbonise the economic system quick sufficient to keep away from local weather chaos; solely a Labour-led authorities can stop Britain’s democratic decay right into a corrupt “Frankenstate” underneath the Tories. 

I used to be a part of the left break up that created the Socialist Alliance in 2001 with Labour in workplace, with the insurgent London mayoral candidate Ken Livingstone victorious and the Tories buried for a decade. However actuality now may be very totally different.

That being mentioned, it’s clear that “labourism” as a political phenomenon is dying: progressive Britain is already fragmented into nationalism and ecopolitics (through the SNP, Plaid Cymru and the Greens). 

If the Labour machine was to purge the entire Socialist Marketing campaign Group, shut down democracy and betray its voters by supporting one other spherical of wars and privatisations, I may see the logic of a brand new celebration – although I shudder on the ideological battles that might engulf it.

However for now the battle continues. An vital a part of that battle is to pressure Keir Starmer to reinstate Corbyn to the Parliamentary Labour Get together and to influence Islington Labour’s members to verify him as their candidate for the following common election.

[See also: The cost-of-living crisis will define 2022 – Labour needs answers now]


Supply hyperlink